Methodology
How Barrel Black Book values bottles
A value that is too high is not a neutral error. It makes a collector overpay. Understating a bottle costs nobody anything; overstating it costs a real person real money. Every rule on this page follows from that.
1. Completed sales set the value
Only realized prices — what someone actually paid at auction for this exact bottle — can set a value. We look at recent results, generally the last three months, so the number reflects today's market rather than last year's.
Every value shows how many verified sales it rests on. A number on its own is an opinion; a count of sales is evidence.
2. The exact bottle, not a close cousin
Batch, release year, proof and size all matter. Two batches of the same barrel-proof bourbon can be different bottles with different prices, and we price them separately. A sale of one is never used to value the other.
3. What doesn't count as a sale
- Auction estimates. A pre-sale estimate is written to attract bidders, and final prices often land at or below its low end. We use estimates to find the ballpark, never as a sale.
- Asking prices. What a seller hopes to get isn't a price.
- Live bids. An open bid is only a floor until the auction closes.
When estimates and completed sales disagree, the sales win. We don't average them or split the difference. When estimates are all there is, we show the low end, label it as an estimate, and report zero sales.
4. Outliers
With three or more sales, anything below 0.4× or above 2.5× the median is set aside before we compute a value. That removes the bottle that sold near retail and the one bidder who overpaid.
With only one or two sales there's no way to tell which one is the outlier, so nothing is trimmed — and the value is marked lower confidence instead.
5. Safeguards built into the system
These rules aren't just guidelines; they're enforced in code before a value ever reaches you:
- Anything labeled as an estimate, ask, bid or guide price is removed from the list of sales.
- The number of sales we report can never exceed the sales we can actually itemize.
- A bottle's value can never exceed the highest price anyone actually paid for it.
Every one of these can only move a value down.
6. Four honest states
Every value tells you which kind of evidence it rests on. We never blur them together.
7. Independence
- No brand, distillery, retailer or sponsor can influence a value. Sponsorship and valuations are kept completely separate.
- We record what collectors buy and sell. We never buy, sell or broker bottles ourselves.
- Our values are informational estimates, not certified appraisals. For insurance claims or estate purposes, use a qualified appraiser.
Keeping score on ourselves
When a bottle we've valued later sells at auction, we compare our number to the real result. Once we have enough history to say something meaningful, we'll publish how close our values land — misses included.
Questions about a specific value? Email us and we'll show you the sales behind it.